The crew who never sleep on the aircraft and the crew who sleep anywhere: the two kinds of long haul crew, the crew rest insomniacs
-
#1 Air France CDG, seven years, the Africa network by choice, and the crew rest threads on this forum are about the bunks and the rotation and the etiquette. This is about the two kinds of crew who use them: the ones who cannot sleep in the bunk no matter what and the ones who sleep anywhere, and the sleep doctor's view of both, because the Air France occupational health ran a sleep study with the long haul crew and I was in it.
The crew rest insomniacs
The crew who lie in the bunk for the rotation's three hours and do not sleep: the engine noise, the turbulence, the body clock that is awake, the anxiety about the service after, the bunk that is too warm or too cold. They come out of the rest more tired than they went in and they do the second service on no sleep and the layover is the first sleep. A quarter of the crew in the study, the doctor said, and more of the senior crew than the junior, because the sleep gets worse with the years (Paul's thread).
The ones who sleep anywhere
The crew who are asleep in the bunk within five minutes of the curtain closing, who sleep on the jumpseat during the cruise if the purser lets them, who sleep on the crew bus and in the hotel lobby and once (a colleague, famous for it) standing in the galley. A quarter of the crew in the study too, mostly the junior ones and the ones who grew up in loud houses, the doctor said, which was a joke and then was not.
The middle
The half who sleep in the bunk sometimes and not others, depending on the rotation, the sector, the body clock, the earplugs (Daniel's), the eye mask, the temperature, the last meal. The study's practical findings were for the middle: the earplugs and the mask always, the bunk cool, no caffeine in the four hours before the rest, the first rest after the service harder than the second (which every purser knows), and the crew who practise a wind down routine in the bunk (the same breathing, the same position) sleep more than the ones who lie there hoping.
What the sleep doctor said about both
That the insomniacs are not doing anything wrong and the bunk is a hard place to sleep and the long haul body clock makes it harder, and that the practical findings help them a little and the years help them less. That the sleep anywhere crew are the lucky ones and the luck fades with the years for most. That the rotation fairness over the month (Chris's thread) matters more for the insomniacs, because the second rest is the one they might get. And that the crew who do not sleep in the bunk should not pretend to the purser that they did, because the fatigue report is the mechanism and the purser's rotation planning depends on knowing who is actually rested.
The honest view
Two kinds of crew and a middle, the bunk a hard place to sleep, the years making it harder, the earplugs and the mask and the cool bunk and the routine as the help, the honesty with the purser as the safety. I am an insomniac in the bunk and a sleeper on the layover and I tell my purser both.
For the long haul crew
Which kind are you, and what works? The study's findings are above and the forum's are below.
-
#2 Virgin, 14 years, and the insomniac in the bunk who sleeps on the layover is me and the honesty with the purser is the thing I ask my crew for and get from half. The sleep anywhere colleague standing in the galley is a legend at every airline and ours is called Dave. Laura has both kinds and the doctor's view.
-
#3 Air NZ purser, and the rotation fairness mattering more for the insomniacs is the thing my spreadsheet does not know and should: the crew who tell me they did not sleep in the first rest get the second next time. The honesty is the rotation's input. Laura's study is the one I wish Air NZ ran.
-
#4 Qantas, and I am the sleep anywhere kind and the luck is fading at eight years, exactly as the doctor said. The five minutes to sleep in the bunk is now fifteen. The earplugs and the mask that I did not need are now in the bag. Laura's doctor was right about the years.
-
#5 SIA, the ULR crew rest, and the 18 hour rotation with five hour rests is the insomniac's nightmare and the sleeper's gift and the Chief knows which is which by the handover. The wind down routine in the bunk is the SIA crew's method and Laura's study has found it.
-
#6 Emirates purser, and the crew who pretend to the purser that they slept are the ones I worry about at the second service and the honest ones are the ones I can roster. Laura's doctor's last point is the purser's whole request. Tell us.
-
#7 JAL purser, and the first rest after the service being harder than the second is the thing every purser knows and the study has confirmed, and the insomniacs get the second rest on my rotations when they tell me. The Japanese crew tell me less. I ask.
